That’s extremely generous for a movie like that. Only my all-time favorites ‘might’ have a 9/10.
Nah, credit where credit is due. I have to use the scale pragmatically and not just reserve 10/10 (or rather 5/5, as it is on MUBI) for the all-time classics. That would be pointless when you watch so many films. So every year, there is at least a handful of 5/5 titles on the top list. I see I actually gave A QUIET PLACE 5/5 on MUBI, even though it was 6th (which would probably translate to 9/10 in that scale). It was a good year.