Reply To: FSM # 3: The $1000.000 Question: What is good [film] music?

#13667
Nicolai P. Zwar
Participant

    Opening up categories, the way I see it, there can be one of several things true about a film score:

    Possible and perfect:

    Great film score and great stand alone music. (Perfection.)

    Also possible:

    Bad film score, but great stand alone music. (When the music just doesn’t work in the movie but is great on its own.)

    Also possible:
    Sufficient film score, but uninteresting on its own. (Functional music, unintrusive, pushes the right buttons, but nothing one listens to on its own.)

    Also possible:
    Bad film score, bad as stand alone music. (No explanation needed, I presume. That music sucks. Hard.)

    Also possible of course:
    Countless in-betweens of neither all out great nor all out bad, whatever…

    There is, however, a category that doesn’t exist:

    Not possible:

    Great film score, but bad stand alone music.
    (That’s just not something that can conceivably exist.)