Reply To: All things STAR TREK….
I’d say that’s a lot of value for your STAR TREK investment, Doc.
In 2010, I did a thread on FSM called “Losing my STAR TREK: TOS virginity“, because I hadn’t seen the original series at that point. Here’s what I said then, in the first post:
“Well, I’ve now seen most of the recommended titles in the first thread, in addition to the first ones (I like to see the start of any new TV show):
THE CAGE (pilot)
WHERE NO MAN HAS GONE BEFORE (pilot)
THE MAN TRAP
CITY ON THE EDGE OF FOREVER
BALANCE OF TERROR
THE NAKED TIME
AMOK TIME
DOOMSDAY MACHINE
THE ENEMY WITHIN
THE MENAGERIE (which was basically just a remake of THE CAGE)
These were, according to the people in the first thread, some of the best episodes ST had to offer, that didn’t include silly rubber monster thingies and so on.
Well, I’m sorry to say that I have to concede to Jehannum’s prediction – none of them are really my cup of tea, and really constitute a type of sci fi that I don’t connect to very easily. They are not that much different from its colleague LOST IN SPACE, IMO; although perhaps slightly less campy. very often, it’s a little too much of this, which kinda turns me off:
That said, my favourite of these was probably THE DOOMSDAY MACHINE. Effects were pretty OK, the narrative tight and credible (within a sci fi setting), with some looming, mythological back stories, which I always love.
I also liked Nimoy’s acting when his logical exterior was under pressure, like in AMOK TIME and one of the other ones, I can’t remember.
I connect far more easily to the “space opera” version (STAR WARS) or the serious approach (ALIEN) than I do this. Sorry. At least I gave it a shot.
Also, I’m not necessarily saying that I won’t be seeing more TOS episodes. There were some nice bits here and there, and there’s probably some of those in episodes I haven’t seen too.”
