Reply To: Importance of booklets and liner notes

#6349
J
Participant

I agree with Thor. However, some are written in a certain (save) format, often for accessible C and C releases. In reviews, it should be about some deeper musical details, in-context use, a deeper understanding of what it does, and overall feeling.

I have had four of my liner notes rejected based on being too comprehensive in addressing all possible aspects, even though I was promised complete freedom and only the limitation of the amount of sentences. Eventually, they wanted a detailed dry analysis of, say, a complete Rambo II, while the film and its use of music required a very different approach. All these cases are almost like a thing I reviewed in recent days: https://www.maintitles.net/reviews/faa-yeung-nin-wa/