Forum

Custom suites/albums

Viewing 8 posts - 31 through 38 (of 38 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #14754
    Dr. Jacoby
    Participant

      I heard some nice fan made suites of scores on YouTube, I always found that kind of disrespectful against the original work and the composer.

      I think it’s far more disrespectful to a composer to do a complete score dump onto a CD without any consideration of pacing or dead weight.

      #14755
      Dr. Jacoby
      Participant

        Since I always “hated” LPs — even back in the day when they were my only true source of music — I sure never had the craving of creating anything that resembles an old-school LP out of an actual full film score (not to mention that I don’t enjoy spending my time editing and pasting and mastering other people’s music… even though I know my way around the tools).

        I am a child of the LP era, and those 15- to 20-minute sides represent a perfect length for digesting music. I don’t know if that is how my brain is hard-wired, or if I was trained to become accustomed to these lengths just through exposure.

        #14758
        Malte Müller
        Keymaster

          I heard some nice fan made suites of scores on YouTube, I always found that kind of disrespectful against the original work and the composer.

          I think it’s far more disrespectful to a composer to do a complete score dump onto a CD without any consideration of pacing or dead weight.

          At best the composer should be involved in both representations. I mean you don’t cut a movement from a classical work at will either (yeah, it is not directly comparable, I know).

          #14763

          I am a child of the LP era, and those 15- to 20-minute sides represent a perfect length for digesting music. I don’t know if that is how my brain is hard-wired, or if I was trained to become accustomed to these lengths just through exposure.

          I am not necessarily a child of the LP era like you (I mean, I kinda am, being born in ’77), but I can very much relate to this. Certainly being of the cassette and subsequently CD age, which had their own limitations. But more than type of medium, what I relate to in what you say is the almost biological experience of a piece of music, and how I feel “full” after LP length. It’s not a strict rule, I’m perfectly capable of stretching myself to a long 75+ minute album now and then, but regardless of music, I feel like I’ve spent the time I want to spend with a specific musical work after about 40-45 minutes.

          Which is why a work can go from being completely uninteresting to totally rewarding just by whittling it down a bit. Like that Thomas Newman example I provided on the previous page. There’s something going on in the brain there that allows for this.

          #14766
          Nicolai P. Zwar
          Participant

            I am a child of the LP era, and those 15- to 20-minute sides represent a perfect length for digesting music. I don’t know if that is how my brain is hard-wired, or if I was trained to become accustomed to these lengths just through exposure.

            I am a child of the LP era, and I hated (not literal “hate”… I just was painfully aware of the shortcomings of the format) them even back then… I always knew one day there had to be a better way to transport music… and now it’s there. LPs had to cut compositions short (I easily digest far longer stretches of music than 15 to 20 minutes), reduced the dynamic range, added hiss, cackles and wear, and had to put the “best” cues first, because the more the needle moved towards the center, the worse the LP sound got. I have hundreds of LPs and owned some excellent turntables (my favorite has been the Technics SL-1200LTD), but as far as music is concerned, I was very happy when the CD arrived.
            And I have no trouble leaving the CD behind, now that digital files make them superfluous.

            But I was like that with movies too… I never much bothered collecting movies in the days of VHS… the format had awful image and sound quality. DVD was much better, but still: European DVDs had often poor sound, as they just sped up the picture to 25 seconds per frame rather than the US 24 frames per second. It wasn’t really noticeable as far as image is concerned, but it was very noticeable in the sound, and especially music. So I had to wait until Blu-ray where I thought: yes, this now is a format that’s good enough.
            Now, in the days of Bluray/4K and UHD streaming, I don’t even go to the theater anymore, I prefer watching movies at home. (I still go to concerts though. 🙂 )

            #14770
            Tom_Servo
            Participant

              Yes, this is my feeling as well, although I was born in ’73 and still lived through enough of that LP/cassette era to be aware of its effect

              I am not necessarily a child of the LP era like you (I mean, I kinda am, being born in ’77), but I can very much relate to this. Certainly being of the cassette and subsequently CD age, which had their own limitations. But more than type of medium, what I relate to in what you say is the almost biological experience of a piece of music, and how I feel “full” after LP length. It’s not a strict rule, I’m perfectly capable of stretching myself to a long 75+ minute album now and then, but regardless of music, I feel like I’ve spent the time I want to spend with a specific musical work after about 40-45 minutes.

              #14772
              Tom_Servo
              Participant

                A composer should certainly be involved in presenting what they feel are the highlights of their score, because not every cue needs to be heard. Some cues simply are there to mark time, to cover a 10-second scene transition, to hold one long sustain under a monologue and are not really listenable outside of the movie. This is all determined by what the film needs and is totally different than composing a concert work, which by it’s very nature doesn’t contain “filler” music as it is only what the composer wants the audience to hear.

                At best the composer should be involved in both representations. I mean you don’t cut a movement from a classical work at will either (yeah, it is not directly comparable, I know).

                #14795
                Blaize
                Participant

                  Super cool, thanks for sharing these track lists for your custom albums! I created three highlights compilations for the GODZILLA series, one each for Showa, Heisei and Millennium eras.

                  Nice! Your Heisei selections remind me of one of Futureland’s compilations from the ’90s.

                  Regarding Ifukube, one score of his I enjoy is “Birth of Japan” (1959). While I do prefer listening to the entire score in one go as I prefer to do with every score, it is nearly two hours long and I unfortunately don’t always have the time to dedicate myself to it. So, I consolidated the score to fit a single disc for my Ifukube science fiction set and it could theoretically work as a separate album.

                  It actually reminds me of what Rhino did with Miklós Rózsa’s “Ben-Hur”, in which both a two disc and a single disc presentation were released. I actually have both of those along with FSM’s gargantuan five disc release.

                  As for Ifukube’s “Birth of Japan”, I’ll provide my track list in case anyone would like to create their own single disc presentation. I used Futureland’s 1992 reissue of the score as my sound source, but some simple editing is required to create the film version of a cue. Otherwise, the Toho Music release couldn’t be used.

                  Here’s the track list:

                  “Birth of Japan” (11/01/1959)
                  01. Main Title (DB-1 M-Title-3)
                  02. Birth of Japan (DB-2 M-Jindai)
                  03. The Emperor and Otomo (DB-3 M-2 OK)
                  04. Kumaso Conquest ‒Take 2‒ (DB-3 M-3 OK)
                  05. Yamato Departure (DB-3 M-4)
                  06. Princess Oto Tachibana (DB-4 M-7)
                  07. Ise Departure ‒Film Version‒ (DB-5 M-8C + PS-26-2 PS 3T Repro Mix)
                  08. West Conquest (DB-5 M-9)
                  09. Faraway Thoughts (DB-6 M-10)
                  10. Kumaso’s Banquet II (PS-45-1 Edit Mix 3T R.R)
                  11. Yamato Takeru’s Triumphant Return (DB-8A M-12)
                  12. Takamagahara (DB-9 M-13A)
                  13. Susanoo-no-Mikoto (DB-9 M-13B)
                  14. Iwato Kagura (PS-60-1 Edit Mix 3T R.R)
                  15. Amaterasu-Ōmikami (DB-11 M-16-2)
                  16. Part Two Opening (DB-11 M-17)
                  17. Susanoo-no-Mikoto’s Wails (DB-11 M-18)
                  18. The Priestess’ Rule (DB-12 M-19)
                  19. Kushinadahime (DB-12 M-21)
                  20. Susanoo-no-Mikoto’s Strategy (DB-13 M-22A)
                  21. Orochi Extermination (DB-13 M-25)
                  22. March of Impatience (DB-14 M-26)
                  23. Two Thoughts (DB-16 M-31)
                  24. Fire Mountain Dance (DB-17 M-33-2)
                  25. Kusanagi-no-Tsurugi (DB-18 M-33A)
                  26. Tornado (DB-20 M-35A)
                  27. Otomo Army Sortie (DB-21 M-36)
                  28. Great Melee (DB-22 M-38)
                  29. Wrath of the Earth (DB-24 M-39)
                  30. Ending (DB-24A M-40)

                Viewing 8 posts - 31 through 38 (of 38 total)
                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.