Forum

Jerry Goldsmith

Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 75 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #15093
    Malte Müller
    Keymaster

      The PAPILLON description make me want to check out that one though. Maybe my wallet and I manage that before even their re-issue is gone 😉

      #15094
      Nicolai P. Zwar
      Participant

        Sonically, Quartet’s Papillon is a considerably more essential upgrade than La-La Land’s Planet of the Apes as far as previous releases go. The Quartet is newly mixed and mastered from the mulit-track session tapes (which were well preserved), I have no idea where the other masters were taken from, but obviously a few generations removed from the master tapes. The Silva Screen was probably the old album master, and the Universal France added some cues (yeah!) but had the wrong pitch (aargh!) because there were some tape speed issues. I still have all these previous releases, but the Quartet is really a big step up from the Silva Screen and the Universal France CD.

        #15096
        KMCG
        Participant

          Yes, I did indeed slightly rearrange the Quartet album, to break up that like for like action/chase music which repeats in film sequence.
          I think the sound on the Silva CD is decent, although I agree that the Quartet remaster offers improved sonics.
          It’s great to live in a world that gives us both.

          #15116

          I’m listening to LIONHEART now, the “Epic Symphonic Score” version, and it sounds great to my ears. Crisp sound, precise playing for so many unusual meter changes, organic mix of synths and acoustic elements. Not sure why Nick wants this re-recorded. Is the other CD version perhaps lesser in quality?

          #15118
          Nicolai P. Zwar
          Participant

            I have no issues with the sound or the electronics; the orchestra is just not really up to the music, and I think that’s very much audible. It’s just not a very good ensemble, no match for the (often used by Goldsmith) National Philharmonic Orchestra or the L.A. Session musicians.

            #15119

            You’re more discerning than I!

            Unless there are really obvious shortcomings, like Horner’s BATTLE BEYOND THE STARS, I’m too dense to get the subtle discrepancies.

            #15123
            Malte Müller
            Keymaster

              Been a while I listened to this or other recordings with that orchestra but doesn’t it often have especialy weakness with brass?

              Probably they grew meanwhile just like the Prague orchestra did that also wasn’t very good or at least on many of their early recordings but on the Tadlows they were.

              #15136
              Nicolai P. Zwar
              Participant

                The Hungarian Orchestra had lots of issues… lack of precision, ensemble balance, intonation and seamless cohesion within the sections… it sounds like a perfunctory assembly of musicians who never performed together who now had to perform the music without without rehearsals. Which it probably was (I really don’t know about the background of this recording). I’d love to hear this music performed by a world class orchestra.

                #15138
                markrayen
                Participant

                  I took my children to see the new Looney Tunes film last weekend. Steven Price is an absolutely brilliant composer, but I lament the abandonment of the great traditions of cartoon music. So I’ve been playing one of Jerry’s last scores, “Looney Tunes: Back in Action” over the last few days. Score was the best part of that film, as I remember it.

                  #15140
                  Malte Müller
                  Keymaster

                    I’d love to hear this music performed by a world class orchestra.

                    That would be surely nice. We’ll see if Leigh Phillips really starts a Kickstarter for it as it surely will be one if. And surely an expensive one. Even if I could imagine the score sheets are available so minus reconstruction work possibly.

                    So I’ve been playing one of Jerry’s last scores, “Looney Tunes: Back in Action” over the last few days. Score was the best part of that film, as I remember it.

                    One of the scores of Goldsmith I don’t have! Is the expaned one worthwhile or is the short album enough? But I remember it being fun as I always had a soft spot for busy cartoon music (I love the two crazy Carl Stalling albums although I really need to be in the mood for them ;-))

                    #15141

                    We talked a bit about LOONEY TUNES: BACK IN ACTION in the “Final scores” thread, if I remember correctly. I maintain what I’ve said for years – I find it a bizarre, almost comical score to go out on for a composer of Goldsmith’s stature. Here’s this composer who gave us PLANET OF THE APES, PATTON, PAPILLON, ALIEN, STAR TREK, what have you. And what did he go out on? Friggin’ LOONEY TUNES: BACK IN ACTION!

                    But obviously, you can’t control these things. Also, I can understand people on the other side, who maintain that it’s kinda fitting, since it was a Joe Dante film, Goldsmith always had a number of clunkers under his belt, and it showcased his supreme craftmanship etc.

                    It must have been gruelling for a composer who neared the end of his life, to work on so many specific split timings and Carl Stalling-like mickey-mousing effects. In all its absurdity, it’s admirable.

                    I’ve always found the OST plenty, especially for this type of score. I didn’t actually know there was an expanded one as well. Wouldn’t that be a terribly whimsical experience?

                    #15143
                    Malte Müller
                    Keymaster

                      Yes, I remember we had it there. Somehow I always thought TIMELINE was the last.

                      I’ve always found the OST plenty, especially for this type of score. I didn’t actually know there was an expanded one as well. Wouldn’t that be a terribly whimsical experience?

                      That’s why I ask. Since I lack many of the later Goldsmiths including this one. The normal album I even saw in a 2nd shop some weeks ago. But there is also a download of the expanded version and often Goldsmith as Nic mentioned work better in expanded form.

                      Both are from Varese and it’s on their bandcamp page which is cheaper than on Qobuz for example (there you get CD prices…). Compare careful there before you download from their bandcamp as for example the AIRFORCE ONE Deluxe release there misses the 2nd half of the album for unknown reasons…

                      #15155
                      Nicolai P. Zwar
                      Participant

                        Indeed, Jerry Goldsmith’s final film score before he passed away was Looney Tunes: Back in Action.

                        It’s a bit like Thor said… this is the composer of Planet of the Apes. Patton. Papillon. Chinatown. Chinatown!!! And of course Alien and Star Trek: The Motion Picture. One of the giants of film music, one of the great architects of the modern film score, and his career ends not with a sweeping historical drama or a profound artistic statement, or a classic science fiction film… but with Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck.

                        And yet… what a way to go. I love Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck. And so does Joe Dante. And apparently, so did Jerry Goldsmith, if his last score is anything to go by.

                        Because Looney Tunes: Back in Action is not like Bernard Herrmann who went out on a somber note with Taxi Driver. Some composers end their career with a work that seems to serve as a Requiem. Sometimes literally, sometimes figuratively. Looney Tunes: Back in Action is the opposite, it sounds like the work of a composer who is having an absolute blast. The score is bonkers, playful, energetic. There is so much stuff going on in the score, every cue seems to contain another joke, another parody, another stylistic detour. No hint of death, no hint of passing. The music is full of life.

                        In many ways, it feels like Goldsmith pulling out all of his Dante-Comedy tricks one last time. Gremlins, Small Soldiers, Explorers, Matinee, The ‘Burbs, take these and throw ’em into an Acme-blender, add some explosives, and see what comes out. It’s a reminder that, while Goldsmith certainly was critically acclaimed and one of the most respected composer in Hollywood, he could also be one of the most entertaining composers. There is a joy in this music which I find exuberating.

                        The recording is bright, detailed and alive, and the orchestra sounds like it is having as much fun as the composer. Now that orchestra is really spot on (unlike the one in Lionheart), the performance is excellent. The Hollywood studio musicians turn on a dime for Goldsmith the same way the Berlin Philharmonic did for Karajan. There is no dead weight in the music, it’s full of musical ideas and doesn’t really ever stop moving. Maybe some may find it tiring, but not because the music is boring, but because it’s so full of stuff.

                        I have often thought of it as Goldsmith’s personal version of “Peter and the Wolf”. Not because the two works are musically similar, but because both are playful celebrations of musical storytelling itself. And kids can have a blast with this music. The score feels like a composer delighting in what music can do, how quickly it can change character, how it can comment on images, parody them, propel them, and occasionally steal the spotlight from them. And sometimes just be silly and goof around. Yet it’s a Goldsmith score, and it’s fully “musical music” at all times.

                        Is it one of the greatest film scores ever written? Is it among Goldsmith’s greatest, deepest works? Probably not. But that is hardly the point. Some scores are meant to be or have chance to become classics. Others, like LOONEY TUNES – BACK IN ACTION, simply deliver fun.

                        As far as which album to choose, I only know the expansion. I have often noted that a lot of Goldsmith albums become dramatically richer when expanded editions appeared because the underlying larger symphonic architecture is more revealed. With Looney Tunes, however, I’d say the moment is what matters more than the arc. The score is built with lots of zany ideas and antics, it’s set pieces, not high drama. I haven’t listened to the original album cut, so far I’ve listened only to the expanded score, although the original soundtrack album cut is included on the expansion. My suspicion is that the principal difference is simply that the album cut simply contains less music… that’s it. So I personally rather have more than less of it (and the expansion also included the contributions of John Debney), but it’s not a case of “the music demands it” here, but simply because more of a fun thing is better than less of a fun thing.

                        And perhaps it is fitting somehow that Goldsmith did not leave us with a final symphonic statement about life, destiny or mortality. Goldsmith’s last score isn’t a reminiscence about the past, not a culmination of his career. Instead, Jerry Goldsmith went out with a grin, with a wink. By all accounts from friends and colleagues, he had a wry sense of humor. Hey, this is the guy who wore an ape mask to the recording sessions of Planet of the Apes!

                        So maybe this was the right score for Goldsmith to sign off after all… with Joe Dante, Bugs Bunny & Daffy Duck. There are worse ways for a master to say goodbye. And I’ve come to really like Goldsmith’s final note. (Couldn’t resist to write this one…)

                        Edit (just a short section of the score… if you wonder if the rest of the score is like that: yes)

                        #15166
                        Malte Müller
                        Keymaster

                          So maybe this was the right score for Goldsmith to sign off after all… with Joe Dante, Bugs Bunny & Daffy Duck.

                          Yeah, maybe and he is as immortal as these cartoon characters are for us. Thanks for the review. Makes me want to get it in the near future.

                          #15175
                          markrayen
                          Participant

                            Such a great perspective, Nicolai. Thanks for sharing!

                          Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 75 total)
                          • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.