Original soundtrack recordings vs. re-recordings?
- This topic has 45 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 3 weeks, 5 days ago by
Cailin.
-
AuthorPosts
-
26. September 2026 at 17:38 #14409
I am not taking the human out of the equation, no two performances of any piece of music are alike. My response was to Malte that it might be easier with an orchestra, which is what I objected to.
Easier is relative of course. We agree on that no music is exactly the same performed by different orchestras. But any orchestra performing a symphony by notes will have that symphony sound like that symphony despite differences in interpretation. There is of course no “original”.
But on synth and other stuff there technically is and any “different tiny parameter” is much more instantly recognizable and feel “wrong” easier. Again, nothing needs to be exactly the same.
(…) possibly because he’s worked with Carpenter and knows exactly what he did. It’s also not overly complicated music, with repeated ostinatos and clear chords.
Yeah, Vangelis was a better example for hard to re-create synth music.
26. September 2026 at 17:51 #14411However, I found Alan Howarth’s performance of ASSAULT ON PRECINCT 13 recreates the exact vibe and sound of John Carpenter’s original score quite well, possibly because he’s worked with Carpenter and knows exactly what he did. It’s also not overly complicated music, with repeated ostinatos and clear chords.
Yes, I think that’s a rather special situation, with Howarth being so deeply involved in the original scores to begin with. Of course, that’s no guarantee either (Franglen and Horner come to mind), but it certainly helps.
10. October 2026 at 20:26 #15045As it happens, there’s a thread now on JWFAN about which scores people would like to see re-recorded. I had a brief peek into it, and I’m struck by the fact that most of the suggestions are of a newer date, with already perfectly-existing recordings, both sound and performance-wise. The mind boggles, but I suppose it’s understandable that many people aren’t so aware of titles “before their time”.
Meanwhile, I think the privilege of re-recordings should go to MUCH older scores, unreleased, or in poor shape. Certainly well before my time.
11. October 2026 at 11:02 #15064I agree, really weird to suggest Kamen’s ROBIN HOOD oder Poledouris’ FLESH + BLOOD. If you are going to spend that much money record something not available or really has bad sounding releases. Somewhere I read about the DRAGONHEART sequels. Don’t remember how the scores are but I remember they were mostly done with sample libraries. That might be something to jusifiy for a technical reasons if he music is really that worth it.
Of newer ones maybe Goldsmith’s RANSOM comes to mind but otherwise it would 1950s and older for me only.
11. October 2026 at 11:50 #15071If I had would re-record something, I’d probably re-record Goldsmith’s Planet of the Apes. I’d be interested to hear a new recording of that, conducted by Esa-Pekka Salonen and the Philharmonia Orchestra or something like that.
11. October 2026 at 11:53 #15073I think the only way I would have condoned a re-recording of a score from the last 50-60 years, is that there is something SERIOUSLY wrong with the original recording, or it’s unreleased and the master tapes are lost.
11. October 2026 at 12:06 #15075The scores I would seriously consider to newly record if I had the means or inclination would be Jerry Goldsmith’s Planet of the Apes and Lionheart, as well als Bernard Herrmann’s Beneath the 12-Mile Reef and The Ghost and Mrs. Muir.
11. October 2026 at 12:40 #15078A re-recording of PLANET OF THE APES might be something but probably hard to get all the sonics right. Probably expensive…
As far as I know LIONHEART is on Leigh Phillips own wish list already… All the Hungarian Symphony Orchestra scores have their issue like HOOSIERS also does.
Beneath the 12-Mile Reef I agree. The Ghost and Mrs. Muir is one of the Herrmann’s I never really could warm up with. What is wrong with the Bernstein re-recording? I think that’s the only version I know (besides having seen the film).
11. October 2026 at 13:40 #15085There’s nothing wrong with the Bernstein recording per se. I just think it would be interesting to hear this in a lush modern recording. Would not by my priority re-recording, but something I’d consider.
My number 1 project would be PLANET OF THE APES. That score could benefit from the sound Salonen got out of the L.A. Philharmonic in his “Le Sacre” recording. Salonen has also voiced his admiration for Jerry Goldsmith and had actually intended to commission something from him; alas, it never came to be. Which is why he’d be my number 1 conductor choice for the project.
And LIONHEART, yes, that’s simply because the orchestra is… well, how to put it… bad. LIONHEART could benefit from a new recording with a top-orchestra. And Beneath the 12-Mile Reef, yeah, that would be way more important than The Ghost and Mrs. Muir.11. October 2026 at 15:06 #15089My number 1 project would be PLANET OF THE APES
But Planet of the Apes is on Project 3.
11. October 2026 at 15:09 #15090But Planet of the Apes is on Project 3.
😉
11. October 2026 at 15:11 #15091And LIONHEART, yes, that’s simply because the orchestra is… well, how to put it… bad.
Yes, true. The question would be with synth that also were used to fix the orchestra unless I am mistaken or a full orchestral only one.
11. October 2026 at 15:33 #15095My number 1 project would be PLANET OF THE APES
But Planet of the Apes is on Project 3.
Ha, yeah… and I’ve got the Project3 soundtrack LP too, which has nice complimentary notes by Charlton Heston.
11. October 2026 at 15:54 #15102Personally, I’ve never had any issues with LIONHEART. Both sound and performance-wise, it sounds absolutely fine to my ears (even before I got tinnitus!). And the Bernstein version of THE GHOST AND MRS. MUIR is all I ever need of this.
But yeah — I’m kinda hardcore on this. If there is ONE version I’m pleased with, I don’t need any more, as we discussed in this thread.
11. October 2026 at 16:03 #15104And the Bernstein version of THE GHOST AND MRS. MUIR is all I ever need of this.
Agreed. I think I mentioned this in another thread, but there is an additional Ghost track on the McNeely 451 album. I bought a lossless download of this track and add it to the Bernstein album. Not sure how much it adds to the overall experience, but in that context, it works better than it does in a grab bag collection.
13. October 2026 at 23:48 #15213The sound of SUPERMAN:THE MOVIE has vastly improved over the re-recordings. The original sound quality isn’t great. At the same time, there’s a bit of nostalgia and warmth to those older recordings that, for lack of a better description, sound slightly off key in how they are presented on the record or disc.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
