Dr. Jacoby
Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Weasels’ Tale, a 2019 comedic thriller from Argentina. Highly recommended, and the score was very nice, too. (I almost never notice scores in films; go figure!).
Sure is. What’s the Antonioni?
A four-disc set of his early B&W films, pre-Blow Up. Composers are Fusco and Gaslini.
What’s your take on bonus material like this in boxed sets? I’ve noticed that it’s actually MORE common now than it was back then.
I have found that with many box sets, regardless of artist or genre, the last disc is generally the least interesting for a variety of reasons. However, those discs often have gems on them. That Lost in Space disc has all the robot lines, correct?
For film/TV music, I have these:
Star Trek TOS
Lost in Space
All of those Irwin Allen TV shows in the fat boy jewel cases
Planet of the Apes (original 5)
Dark Shadows
Twilight Zone
Outer Limits
Antonioni
3 different Legrand boxes
3 different Lalo Schifrin boxes
Quincy Jones
2 crime jazz boxes
The Prisoner
Randall and Hopkirk
The Saint
Danger Man
Mission: Impossible
Serge Gainsbourg film music
2 Nicolai
Morricone/Nicolai Dimensioni Sonore
CinecittaI think that’s all of them. That’s enough.
I have only The Tenant and Ghost Story. I can’t remember much about the former – I need to revisit – but I love the film. And I LOVE Ghost Story, which I saw in the theatre when it was released. I saw it with my friend and I drove. I remember after I dropped him off, I was afraid to look in the rearview mirror! I’ve had the LP for several years, and I picked up the expanded CD in one of Quartet’s clearance sales (which we did not seem to get this summer).
31. August 2026 at 14:12 in reply to: FSM # 3: The $1000.000 Question: What is good [film] music? #13814Yeah, it otherwise sounds a bit like the non film score fan saying “The best film music is which you don’t notice” 😉
Well, I have thousands of film scores, and I largely feel that the best film music should not call attention to itself, so I don’t know where that places me.
I guess it boils down to the fact that when I’m listening to an album, I don’t care how it functions in the film. I love the 20-minute suite of L. Bernstein’s On the Waterfront and Ellington’s Anatomy of a Murder album, but I didn’t think either of them worked at all as film scores in the respective films. I don’t know if the instincts of the composers were off, or if someone in the music department placed the music in the wrong locations.
Conversely, I like Carter Burwell’s music for Coen brothers films, and Michael Nyman’s music for Peter Greenaway films, but I would not enjoy these as standalone albums.
30. August 2026 at 21:05 in reply to: FSM # 3: The $1000.000 Question: What is good [film] music? #13807I am much more inclined to notice “bad” film music than good. And the bad music may not necessarily be bad on its own terms, but simply not serving the film.
Coincidentally, we just saw him in Antonioni’s “The Passenger,” in which he asks Maria Schneider if she believes in coincidences.
23. August 2026 at 16:34 in reply to: The Celluloid Tunes Zoom Chats! #3: December 4th, 2026 (Christmas Edition!) #13552That was fun! I realized that it’s probably been a few years since I was engaged in a lengthy film music conversation. Thanks, all!
16. August 2026 at 18:30 in reply to: Which composers do you consider brillant at writing memorable melodies? #13406Indeed… could well be. Not sure if that’s always the case, but probably most of the time. “Melody” is probably most often the starting point.
I should clarify that I am really talking about situations where the film composer is deliberately setting out to write a hit song, like “Moon River.” If we are talking about melody as related to a full score, then I agree with you, melody is only one element to be considered.
16. August 2026 at 18:13 in reply to: Which composers do you consider brillant at writing memorable melodies? #13404It’s hard for me to think of music as just “melody”. Melody is just one element of music, So there is also harmony, rhythm, texture, timbre, dynamics… etc.
Because a great composer can take a melody and do great things with it, whereas a melody might in itself have potential, but if that isn’t realized, it’s just a “melody”.But when a composer sets out to write a memorable melody, the other elements you mention (harmony, rhythm, texture, timbre, dynamics) are likely to come later, certainly the last three will. Granted, harmony and rhythm are tied to melody, but they also don’t have to be in the forefront of the composer’s mind. The rhythmic and harmonic variations can come later.
Among composers you would generally consider “versatile,” do you find that some tend to maintain their own signature sound more than others, and if so, is that an asset or a drawback?
For example, I consider Morricone – who is my top film composer, incidentally – to be very versatile, yet he still manages to consisentently sound like Morricone to my ears.
On the other hand, I think Goldsmith is equally versatile, but he can completely fool me. I remember picking up Sebastian and thinking that it sounded like a Euro score. It didn’t even sound like the scores for the Flint films, which cover similar territory and date from the same period.
Did anyone else think that Conclave perfectly sets itself up for a parody?
I’m not dragging much new stuff home these days. My two most recent soundtrack acquisitions are the new recording of The Ipcress File by John Barry and a twofer of Mephisto Waltz/The Other by J-Go.
If we include compilations and library music, we must have more film music from Italy than any country other than the U.S. And if our film music accumulation skews slightly to the U.S., that says more about proximity and availability more than anything.
I think, the difference between older generation masters like John Williams or Jerry Goldsmith and even James Horner was that when they wanted to sound modern, they often sounded modern in a quite old fashioned way, like they had stopped listening to pop music after 1972.
This is one of the reasons I love pop music in film scores. The composers are woefully out of their depth, but paradoxically come up with fake pop music that is much more interesting and subversive than what the kids are producing.
14. August 2026 at 14:11 in reply to: Which composers do you consider brillant at writing memorable melodies? #13324Most film composers never wrote a standard. A short list of those who have:
Henry Mancini
Michel Legrand
Victor Young
Bronislaw Kaper
David RaksinThere must be others, but these are the only ones I can think of a 8 in the morning.
Goldsmith, Piccioni.
14. August 2026 at 14:01 in reply to: Which composers do you consider brillant at writing memorable melodies? #13321Henry Mancini. Pick up any album of his, and there are at least 5 or 6 tracks that are just as memorable as the hit.
“Groovy/Now Sound” and “Space-Age Bachelor Pad”.
Seriously? That is one of the easiest distinctions. Nothing with even a hint of Beatles influence can go in Space Age Age Bachelor Pad. That is pure Eisenhower/Kennedy-era bliss.
That seems to be an interesting and rather unorthodox way to sort records. Do you have markers to separate the genres? How do you decide what goes into “jazz” and what goes into “crime jazz”, or “Space-Age Bachelor Pad” and “Space/Fantasy/Supernatural”? And what is “Zodiac”?
Yes, we use trashed thrift store vinyl as section dividers, with the name of the genre written in silver ink.
As with any system of filing, ours has its limitations. For example, do the Mort Garson Zodiac albums go in the Zodiac section or the Moog section? I generally settle on wherever I would think to look first.
Most jazz soundtracks go in the Crime Jazz section. However jazz tone-poems about the concrete jungle also go in the crime jazz section. Certain jazz albums will also go into the Space-Age Bachelor Pad section, depending on a combination of theme, packaging, instrumentation, et.
Space/Fantasy/Supernatural is mostly soundtracks in those genres, although concept albums like Russ Garcia’s Fantastica go there too.
But what about your physical collection…. CDs, LPs, Cassette Tapes, 8-Track… whatever you have.
I know some people who file alpha by artist without any sort of genre demarkations. We have a roomful of LPs and CDs, and we have to file by genre to have any idea of what we have. So, we file alpha by artist within a particular genre. A single artist may be filed in as many as 4 or 5 different sections. Genres include the following:
Groovy/Now Sound
Classical
Jazz
Crime Jazz
Spy
Space-Age Bachelor Pad
Jazz/Pop Vocals
Exotica
Hawaiian
Space/Fantasy/Supernatural
Latin Jazz
Brasilian
Rock/Pop
Soul/R&B
Moog
French
Sitar
Zodiac
International
OtherI only have Force Majeure of those albums. I quite like it. The Stratosfear title track is also good, it was used on a norwegian science tv program in the 80s.
Stratosfear is one of my favourite TD albums, right there at the cusp between the old experimental sound and the new, more poppy sound.
Thank you both!
We have only two Tangerine Dream albums, which we are spinning now: Force Majeure (1979) and Stratosfear (1976). Where do connoisseurs rank these two among TD’s oeuvre?
Coincidentally, we were drinking tangerine juice while the albums were playing.
Not sure how I feel about the harmonica on Stratosfear. Our pad is generally a harmonica-free zone.
Last night, we watched on Amazon Prime Cargo, confusingly titled Cargo Space is Cold in the U.S. We both really liked it. I’m not sure if I understood a few subtleties, but I don’t want to post any spoilers. It more or less fits my aesthetic of slow-moving films that attempt to capture the vastness of space and time.
Nice! I’m not convinced the film is for you, but I hope so.
If it’s atmospheric and has no monsters, that bodes well!
I’ve always gotten Billy Goldenberg and Pat Williams mixed up. Why? Both architects of the 70s urban sound, and both are underrepresented on LP and CD.
We watched about 20 or 30 minutes of Barbie. That was enough.
The other hyped film from that year, Oppenheimer, and while we got through the whole thing, I didn’t like it, either.
But as long as we’re talking films called CARGO, and since this is the sci fi thread, I want to recommend the incredibly underrated, Swiss space film from 2009, by Ivan Engler and Ralph Etter, which is really great. Wonderful atmosphere, a bit like ALIEN, but there are no monsters in it. I wrote a brief review of it in 2011, which can be viewed here, in Google translated form. Heartily, heartily recommended.
On Amazon Prime in the U.S. We are watching this weekend!
Could be! Plus, the stereo [Pet Sounds} is “artificial” (meaning post-converted).
Actually, it’s true stereo, it’s just that it had never been mixed to stereo until the 1990s.
-
AuthorPosts
